SkillMeat Beta Feedback Form¶
Thank you for testing SkillMeat! Your detailed feedback helps us prioritize improvements for GA release. This form should take 10-15 minutes to complete.
Submission deadline: End of Week 4 (survey link valid until then)
Section 1: Participant Information¶
Name: [Your name or handle]
Organization: [Company, open source project, individual]
Email: [Contact email for follow-up]
Role (select one): - [ ] Skill Developer (create and share skills) - [ ] Team Lead (manage team collections and sharing) - [ ] Individual User (personal productivity) - [ ] Other: ___
Platform (select one): - [ ] macOS (Intel) - [ ] macOS (Apple Silicon) - [ ] Linux (Ubuntu/Debian) - [ ] Linux (Other): ___ - [ ] Windows 10 - [ ] Windows 11 - [ ] WSL 2
Python Version: [e.g., 3.11.2]
Claude Code/IDE: [e.g., Claude.app for macOS, VS Code extension, Claude.dev]
Section 2: Usage Metrics¶
Duration: How many days did you actively use SkillMeat? - [ ] 1-3 days (light testing) - [ ] 4-7 days (moderate testing) - [ ] 8-14 days (active testing) - [ ] 15+ days (heavy usage)
Features Tested (check all that apply): - [ ] CLI commands (add, remove, list, show, etc.) - [ ] Web interface (browser-based management) - [ ] Team sharing (export/import bundles) - [ ] MCP server management (deploy, health check, logs) - [ ] Marketplace (search, install, publish) - [ ] Configuration management (config get/set) - [ ] Skill updates and version management - [ ] Integration with GitHub - [ ] Telemetry/metrics collection
Collection Size: Approximately how many skills did you install? - [ ] 1-5 skills - [ ] 6-20 skills - [ ] 21-50 skills - [ ] 50+ skills
Most Used Feature: Which feature did you use most frequently? [Open text response]
Section 3: Satisfaction Ratings¶
Scale: 1 = Very Dissatisfied, 5 = Very Satisfied
| Aspect | Rating | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Experience | 1 2 3 4 5 | |
| Ease of Installation | 1 2 3 4 5 | |
| CLI Usability | 1 2 3 4 5 | |
| Web Interface Design | 1 2 3 4 5 | |
| Documentation Clarity | 1 2 3 4 5 | |
| Performance & Speed | 1 2 3 4 5 | |
| Feature Completeness | 1 2 3 4 5 | |
| Error Messages | 1 2 3 4 5 |
Section 4: Open Feedback¶
What Worked Well?¶
What aspects of SkillMeat impressed you or worked smoothly? Be specific.
[Open text response - 100-500 words]
What Was Frustrating?¶
What caused confusion, errors, or friction? Include context and specific examples.
[Open text response - 100-500 words]
What Features Are Missing?¶
What features would make SkillMeat essential for your workflow?
[Open text response - 100-500 words]
Would You Use SkillMeat After GA Release?¶
- [ ] Definitely (plan to use immediately)
- [ ] Probably (depends on addressing feedback)
- [ ] Maybe (needs significant improvements)
- [ ] Unlikely (not aligned with my needs)
Why? [Open text response - 50-200 words]
Section 5: Bug Reports¶
Report any bugs you discovered. Complete one table row per bug.
| # | Description | Steps to Reproduce | Severity | Affected Feature |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | [Brief description] | 1. Run X 2. Observe Y 3. See Z |
P0/P1/P2/P3 | [Feature name] |
| 2 | [Brief description] | [Steps] | P0/P1/P2/P3 | [Feature name] |
| 3 | [Brief description] | [Steps] | P0/P1/P2/P3 | [Feature name] |
Severity Scale: - P0: System crashes, data loss, security vulnerability - P1: Major feature broken, cannot complete core workflow - P2: Feature works with workaround, causes inconvenience - P3: Minor issue, cosmetic problem, low impact
For each bug, also provide: - Error message (exact text or screenshot) - Environment (OS version, Python version, SkillMeat version) - Impact frequency (always, sometimes, rarely) - Workaround (if any)
Section 6: Feature Requests¶
Share ideas for improvements and new features.
| Priority | Feature Name | Use Case | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| High | [Feature] | [Why you need it] | [Additional context] |
| Medium | [Feature] | [Why you need it] | [Additional context] |
| Low | [Feature] | [Why you need it] | [Additional context] |
Section 7: Documentation Feedback¶
Which Parts Were Helpful?¶
[Checkboxes for documentation sections you found useful] - [ ] Quickstart guide - [ ] CLI commands reference - [ ] Web interface guide - [ ] Team sharing guide - [ ] MCP management guide - [ ] Troubleshooting guide - [ ] FAQ - [ ] Other: ___
Documentation Issues¶
Did you encounter any of these issues?
| Issue | Example | Severity |
|---|---|---|
| Missing Information | [What was missing?] | High/Medium/Low |
| Unclear Explanation | [What was confusing?] | High/Medium/Low |
| Outdated Documentation | [What was wrong?] | High/Medium/Low |
| Wrong Code Example | [What failed?] | High/Medium/Low |
| Unclear Terminology | [What was confusing?] | High/Medium/Low |
Section 8: Platform & Environment¶
Installation Experience¶
Did you encounter any issues during installation?
- [ ] No issues - smooth install
- [ ] Minor issues but worked out (describe below)
- [ ] Significant issues (describe below)
- [ ] Unable to install
Details if needed: [Open text]
Performance¶
Did you notice any performance issues?
- [ ] No issues - fast and responsive
- [ ] Minor slowness in specific areas
- [ ] Noticeable slowness affecting usability
- [ ] Frequent crashes or freezes
If slowness/crashes, describe: [Open text]
Cross-Platform Compatibility¶
If you tested on multiple platforms, compare your experience:
| Platform | Works Well | Has Issues | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| [OS 1] | [ ] | [ ] | |
| [OS 2] | [ ] | [ ] | |
| [OS 3] | [ ] | [ ] |
Section 9: Advanced Topics (Optional)¶
Team Features¶
If you tested team sharing features:
- Ease of exporting bundles: 1 2 3 4 5
- Ease of importing bundles: 1 2 3 4 5
- Usefulness for team collaboration: 1 2 3 4 5
- Missing team features: [Open text]
MCP Server Management¶
If you tested MCP features:
- Ease of deploying servers: 1 2 3 4 5
- Health check reliability: 1 2 3 4 5
- Log viewing functionality: 1 2 3 4 5
- Missing MCP features: [Open text]
Marketplace¶
If you tested marketplace features:
- Search functionality: 1 2 3 4 5
- Discovery experience: 1 2 3 4 5
- Installation process: 1 2 3 4 5
- Missing marketplace features: [Open text]
Section 10: Overall Assessment¶
NPS Question: How likely are you to recommend SkillMeat to other developers? - Scale: 0 (not at all likely) to 10 (very likely) - Your score: ____
Why did you choose that score? [Open text response - 50-200 words]
Top 3 Priorities for GA Release¶
What are the 3 most important things to fix/improve before GA?
- [Priority 1]
- [Priority 2]
- [Priority 3]
Section 11: Additional Comments¶
Use this space for any feedback not covered above:
[Open text response - optional, up to 500 words]
Submission¶
- [ ] I've completed all required sections
- [ ] I've provided specific examples where possible
- [ ] I've checked my responses for clarity
- [ ] I've reviewed the code of conduct and agree to it
Submit: [Form submission button]
Thank you for your valuable feedback!
We'll review all responses and prioritize issues based on severity and frequency. You'll receive a follow-up email with GA release date and how your feedback influenced the final product.
How Your Feedback Will Be Used¶
- Categorization: Feedback tagged by type (bug, feature, UX issue, docs)
- Deduplication: Similar issues combined and prioritized by frequency
- Analysis: Ratings and metrics compiled into summary report
- Prioritization: Engineering team uses feedback to prioritize remaining work
- Communication: Blockers shared publicly, progress updates sent weekly
- Recognition: Contributors thanked in release notes
Data Privacy¶
Your feedback will be: - Stored securely in our feedback system - Analyzed by the SkillMeat team - Summarized in public retrospective (anonymized) - Used to improve future releases
Your email will NOT be: - Shared with third parties - Used for marketing without permission - Stored longer than 12 months - Accessible to public discussions